The show must go on, as the saying goes, and nowhere is that more evident than on Broadway in 2024. Broadway continues to be the heart of America’s unique and vibrant tapestry of storytelling. 

With productions ranging from revivals of classic tales to innovative new works that push the boundaries of theater, there truly is no place like Broadway for show business – to borrow from the iconic Broadway master, Irving Berlin. 

Among the plethora of shows gracing the stage, this list stands out as they capture the hearts and imaginations of audiences and critics alike, making them among the best 5 Broadway shows in 2024.

1. Hamilton: An American Musical


Hamilton: An American Musical is considered a groundbreaking Broadway production. The show features a vibrant blend of hip-hop, jazz, and R&B musical stylings as it tells the story of Alexandar Hamilton, one of America’s founding fathers. 

The musical, created by Lin-Manuel Miranda, has been celebrated for its innovative casting of non-white actors as historical figures. Trey Curtis stars as Alexander Hamilton, and Jared Dixon plays his rival Aaron Burr. The diverse cast challenges traditional narratives and offers a fresh perspective on America's past. 

The show's immense popularity and critical acclaim are evidenced by its numerous awards, including the Pulitzer Prize for Drama and 11 Tony Awards. It has certainly secured its place in the pantheon of musical legends and as one of the best Broadway shows in New York.

2. Wicked


Wicked is an imaginative Broadway musical that offers a fresh perspective on the Land of Oz before Dorothy's arrival in the iconic classic. This prequel to The Wizard of Oz stars Mary Kate Morrissey as Elphaba, the future Wicked Witch of the West, and Alexandra Socha as Glinda, the Good Witch.  

The narrative tells the story of the unlikely friendship between the two before rivalry erupts. It explores themes of identity, acceptance, and the true nature of wickedness in a humorous way, making it one of the best comedy Broadway shows in NYC.

Wicked’s spectacle of magical effects, along with the fanciful performances, explain why it is also considered one of the best kid-friendly Broadway shows NYC has to offer. Moreover, its numerous awards will cement its legacy as a Broadway favorite for years to come.

3. Water for Elephants


Water for Elephants, the Broadway musical adaptation of Sara Gruen's beloved novel, has captivated audiences at the Imperial Theatre since its opening in March 2024. Directed by Tony Award nominee Jessica Stone, the story unfolds through the eyes of Grant Gustin's portrayal of Jacob Jankowski, who finds solace and adventure within a traveling circus after experiencing a personal tragedy. 

It’s a poignant tale of second chances and the magic of love, explored against the backdrop of the Depression-era circus. The spectacle-filled performances lend to its description as a dazzling and thrilling experience, making it one of the best Broadway shows in New York.

4. Hell’s Kitchen


Hell's Kitchen is a vibrant Broadway show that captures the essence of New York City through the music and lyrics of 16-time Grammy Award winner Alicia Keys. The musical tells the coming-of-age story of Ali, played by Maleah Joi Moon. 

Ali is a 17-year-old girl with a fiery spirit who searches for freedom and her life’s purpose amidst the backdrop of the iconic neighborhood. This is a New York City story like no other, full of energy, music, and heart, that showcases the city's raw and dynamic culture and highlights the diverse tapestry of dreams and struggles within the urban landscape. 

The show has garnered critical acclaim, earning two Tony Awards and an impressive 13 nominations. It has certainly earned the title of one of the best Broadway musicals New York has to offer in 2024.

5. MJ: The Musical


MJ: The Musical is a thrilling Broadway spectacle that celebrates Michael Jackson's artistry through his iconic music and signature dance moves. Elijah Rhea Johnson’s masterful portrayal of MJ, along with Tony Award-winning choreography by Christopher Wheeldon, takes the show deep into the creative genius behind Jackson's legendary status. 

Centered around the making of his 1992 Dangerous World Tour, the show provides a multifaceted look at the complexities of fame and creativity. It highlights the legacy of a global superstar and the transformative power of the music that shaped the soundtrack for a generation. 

What to Know Before You Go

There are a few things you should know before attending a Broadway show. Here are some tips that will ensure everyone has a good time:

  • Arrive early so you can find your seat and get comfortable.
  • Go to the bathroom before the show to avoid missing anything and disturbing other guests.
  • Put your phone on airplane mode, and don’t talk during the show or sing along with the musicals. 
  • No taking pictures or videos during the show – it’s illegal. 
  • Make it a special event by dressing for a lovely evening out. 

Stay in Luxury While You Enjoy Broadway's Best

While enjoying this selection of the best 5 Broadway shows in 2024, stay with us at The Lucerne Hotel in Manhattan’s Upper West Side. Our boutique hotel offers luxury accommodations and modern amenities for a memorable visit.